Fireworks

CD Reviews

Magentic - 'In The Dream' http://www.rocktopia.co.uk/media/reviews/photos/thumbnail/200x200s/4f/fa/f8/3579_magenticinthedream_1370044997.jpg Hot

Added by Central Electronic Brain     May 31, 2013    
 
0.0
 
0.0 (0)
6192   0   1   0   0   0

Artist

Artist

Title

Label

Disappointing.

This album was originally released in 2010, but only became available worldwide in March 2012 through the usual internet outlets: although a promotional copy has only just found its way to Fireworks and Rocktopia for review. 

Magentic formed in Israel in 2003 as a standard tribute band, but then began crafting their own progressively orientated material with diverse influences and in 2006 began work on their debut album. Four years in the making, concept album ‘In The Dream’ is a 23-song set spread over two discs. When I saw they were a progressive band with shared male and female lead vocals I was eagerly anticipating something along the likes of Mostly Autumn. Sadly not!

Fireworks - The Ultimate Magazine For Melodic Rock Music

This website uses cookies to help us give you the best experience when you visit. Cookies used for the essential operation of the site have already been set. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. To find out more about the cookies we use and how to delete them, see our Privacy Statement.

I accept cookies from this site


Several styles such as Rock, Punk, Funk, Grunge and Classical are all incorporated into the Magentic sound, which creates a variety of moods, but also gives the music an overall cluttered and disjointed feel. Throwing in some occasional off-kilter vocals and lyrics that range from odd to weird to often downright bizarre doesn’t bode well for an enjoyable listening experience – and I couldn’t even begin to explain the storyline running through the album; but with song-titles like ‘Slap The Monkey To Sleep’ and ‘Raging Hormones And Surging Endorphins’ it’s probably best not to try. I know it wouldn’t be progressive music without pushing some boundaries, but there are just too many extreme diversities within the music for it to work as a whole. Certain parts of the music are entertaining enough, but then they’re counteracted by parts that are just plain irritating, and come across as too damn smug for their own good.

Disappointing is the only way I can summarise an album that on the face of it seemed to have plenty of potential.

Ant Heeks

Share this on the web.

User reviews

There are no user reviews for this listing.

 


Comments (1)add comment

Franco Cerchiari said:

...
Yeah, Magentic. I tried, I really tried to get into this. There are occasions I enjoy reflective, world music. In my opinion Ion's Immaculada (a side project of metal master Duncan Patersen of Anathema and Anti-Matter,) is a glorious, beautiful collection of music that is both soft and reflective. Difference is, on Ion's releases, the feel of the opening track continues throughout the CD's entire playing time drawing the listener into what it is the songwriter is trying to convey. Here, I got lost, with so many styles, vibes and tempos.

A concept album that "....tells a story about love and alternate realities in a world where there's nothing money can't buy," In the Dream opens with "Some Day," where the female and male voices of Dorin Mandelbaum and Boaz Peleg do a sort of accapella warble of vocal pitches and volumes. Tough to sit through at first, but within a few moments a soft piano comes into view, and then the song becomes quite beautiful - gentle, relaxing and easy on the ears. But then track 2 comes along, "Morning, Part 1," and I just had to take off the headphones. Jarring, with it's arpeggio beats and a give and take between different guitar riffs, the vocals were presented into a spoken, quicken pace type, that becomes more than one can listen to. Track 4, "Human, Part 2," didn't fare much better, as it sounded like all the instruments were in a footrace all trying to get to the finishing line first. I gave up quickly. Track 9, "How Nice..." featured classical guitar that played along nicely with a soft bass guitar adding a great underscore.

"My Precious," "In The Dream," the Beatles-esque "What's Real," (with what sounded like an accompaniment of cellos,) were strong and the closing track, the short 1:49 minute "Some Day We Will Fall In Love," was touching with some heartfelt lyrics, (....some day our hands will join, and holding hands will make our fears subside, our warmth flowing back and forth, from my hands to yours and from yours to mine. You fill the places fear likes to find.....all we have to do is some day fall in love..." This truly was a beautiful track, that I did listen to several times.

Comparing themselves to King Crimson, and Pink Floyd may be a bit of a stretch. I could hear influences of Kayak and early Genesis in their songs, but this was tough to listen to in one take. Way to much going on, way to many styles to throw at a listener at once and the end result is the CD doesn't play out nicely. It quickly becomes convoluted. Dorin Mandelbaum - vocals, flute, Boaz Peleg - vocals, guitar, Uri Katvan - guitar, Erez Aminpour - bass, vocals, all very talented indeed but this was just way to much of everything.

(note - I did not have a hard copy of this CD, but instead I heard it from a CD purchasing website - CDbaby.com, where I paid for each individual track.)



 
September 21, 2013
Votes: +0

Write comment

security image
Write the displayed characters


busy

Member Login



Calendar

<<  October 2020  >>
 Mo  Tu  We  Th  Fr  Sa  Su 
     1  2  3  4
  5  6  7  8  91011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031 

Search Here

Shout Here

Latest Message: 3 weeks, 1 day ago
  • daveomd : Got it along with my download, everything looks great! Thanks, Dave
  • Berny : @daveomd: We sent you a mail immediately after your purchase, and have just sent another email now. Please contact me at «email» should you not receive it. Many thanks!
  • daveomd : I purchased your latest issue #92 but never received my download.
  • Berny : @Hysteria & @KI2000: Many thanks for your kind words! :)
  • Hysteria : Received my download copy almost immediately and downloaded 50 magazines for free. Cannot complain! Thanks guys!!!
  • KI2000 : Love the new issue guys, great magazine!
  • Berny : @Mugi89: Your confirmation mail was sent on the 22nd, I've just sent it again. Please contact me at «email» should you not receive it. Many thanks!
  • Mugi89 : Hi! I purchased my digital copy of issue 92 2 days ago but still didn't receive it. When am I gonna be able to download it? thanks
  • Berny : @zom414: Your mail was forwarded to the Fireworks team yesterday, I am going to ask them again. Sorry for the delay!
  • Berny : @Mitch Perry: Your order was received at 4AM local time. As stated on the order page, all payments have to be processed manually. Your copy of Fireworks 92 was added to your download section, many thanks for the purchase.
  • Berny : @RobC68: I sent you two emails explaining the situation. There's not much more I can do for you at the moment, so I'd suggest you stop buying the magazine. Thanks.
  • zom414 : Still not received the latest issue by post, I've emailed as well but not heard anything. Can you let me know what's happening please?
  • Mitch Perry : Can I have my download link, please? Issue 92 22 Sep 2020 07:57:11 BST Paypal Transaction ID: 1BS38875MX3700248
  • RobC68 : purchased issue 92 in download version. been waiting more than a day....PATHETIC SERVICE as it happens with every purchase!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • Berny : @rgilman: Please check your e - mail for download instructions.
  • rgilman : Hello I bought the Deep Purple issue how do I download it? Thanks
  • Berny : @jharper36: Please check your e - mail.
  • jharper36 : Hi, i purchased the download of issue #92. How do I download it?
  • Berny : @loudjlopez: Sorry for the troubles, pls. check your mail. Many thanks!
  • loudjlopez@m : Any word on my digital download of issue 91. Paid on Saturday. It is Tuesday. Thanks
  • loudjlopez@m : Paid for Fireworks #91 for digital download. No word since Saturday and it is Monday.
  • Berny : @fdr: Magazines were sent on Monday. Thanks for your purchase and best regards, B. :)
  • fdr : Hi, yesterday (august 12th) I sent you a payment for 21GBP for the purchase of issues 91 and 82 of Fireworks magazine. (code 7D3182072X778721A) but still haven't received a word od confirmation. Can you please check?
  • Rocktopia Te : @kbm1983: Currently, all orders have to be be processed manually. This could take a few hours. Sorry for the delay, you shoulkd have received a mail containing download instructions by now. @ all: Pls. do not worry in case you see a PayPal transaction error message. Your order was received, pls. do not order the magazine twice. Many thanks for your understanding!
  • kbm1983 : Hi, I bought #91 earlier today but its still not in my downloads. Can you check it out please. Thanks!
  • Rocktopia Te : @ Man Shaped Wolf: You should have received a mail containing download instructions yesterday. Sorry for the delay!
  • Man Shaped W : Hey, same as defron but for 91 :) excited to read our review
  • Berny : @Defron: Can you pls. check your mail? Many thanks, B. :)
  • Defron : Hi guys. Bought #90 couples of hours ago but still not in my downloads . Can you check pls regards Ro
  • Berny : @SoCal Rocker: Welcome back! There are 50 free issues of Fireworks Magazine for you (and of course all other Rocktopians) to download. Check out the news on the frontpage. Stay happy, safe & healthy. Best wishes to California!

Only registered users are allowed to post

Follow Us

FacebookTwitterYoutubeGoogle

This website uses cookies to help us give you the best experience when you visit. Cookies used for the essential operation of the site have already been set. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. To find out more about the cookies we use and how to delete them, see our Privacy Statement.

I accept cookies from this site